Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Eat to live, not live to eat - ब्रह्मार्पणं ब्रह्म हविः

The Instrument, the Object, the Doer, and the Act—All Are Brahman

The instrument, the object, the doer, and the act of offering are all Brahman. (One who considers thus) the state of Brahman alone is the destination worthy of such a person who is steadfast in selfless deeds.

brahmārpaṇaṃ brahma haviḥ brahmāgnau brahmaṇā hutam ।
brahmaiva tena gantavyaṃ brahmakarmasamādhinā ॥

ब्रह्मार्पणं ब्रह्म हविः ब्रह्माग्नौ ब्रह्मणा हुतम् ।
ब्रह्मैव तेन गन्तव्यं ब्रह्मकर्मसमाधिना ॥

brahmArpaNaM brahma haviH brahmAgnau brahmaNA hutam ।
brahmaiva tena gantavyaM brahmakarmasamAdhinA ।।

This is another mantra/śloka that is very well known, written in very simple Sanskrit yet carrying a far-reaching meaning. Appearing in the Bhagavad Gītā (4.24), this is a śloka commonly recited before eating food.

There are multiple parallel meanings here, and we can benefit from this at all levels.

The Yajña Analogy

When a yajña (fire ritual) is performed, there is:

The performer
The fire
The offering (ghee)
The ladle used to offer (the ghee)
All of them are simultaneously the same supreme principle—Brahman, the Parama-Brahma.

Now think of the act of eating:

There is the eater.
There is the digestive fire.
There is the food.
There is the hand used to put the food in the "fire."
It is similar to the act of yajña.

Why Is It Important or Even Relevant Here?

Eating is a specific example of consumption, where we don’t create but consume—we take away from the system.

We may do this with a sense of pride—See, I am eating at a seven-star hotel, enjoying a twelve-course meal. I am so great, powerful, and successful!

Or we could be eating a simple loaf of bread with no milk, just water to push it down.

Why Do We Eat?

The primary reason is to get energy and maintain the life force. But over time, with our ever-wandering minds, we have devised delicious cuisines that serve more as a subject of the tongue rather than the stomach!

We have levels of cutlery, food, ambiance, and concerns over where and how we eat. The act of eating has become an event in itself, a symbol of status in society. It was customary for the rich (royalty) to leave some food on their plate as a sign of abundance and opulence.

But in the end, we all have a small stomach that simply needs nutrients to sustain the life force.

We should not get distracted by the act of eating—it is not the destination but just a means to survive. (This is meant in the broader sense, not in the momentary sense.)

We should not pay too much attention to what we are eating, nor to our status or importance because of what, where, and how we are eating.

Eating Without Ego

When animal sacrifices used to be performed, this verse served as a means to stay level-headed:
  • I am not superior because I killed this animal.
  • I am simply doing this to survive.
  • Life force is using life force to sustain life force.
We should have no pride in what we eat.

At the level of eating, we should be guided by the stomach (nutrition) rather than the tongue (taste).

Eat to live, not live to eat.

Expanding This to Any Act of Consumption

Our importance is not based on what we consume or what we can afford to consume.

It is all Brahman—nothing special about us.

This attitude grounds us a bit—good therapy for the ego!

Expanding This to Any Deed, Action, or Karma

There is:
  1. The doer
  2. The deed
  3. The instruments of doing
  4. The energy of doing
All of them are Brahman.

For example, if you cut wood and make a chair:
  1. You (the carpenter) are Brahman.
  2. The saw is Brahman.
  3. The wood is Brahman.
  4. The energy used to cut is also Brahman.
Nothing special!

When we do things with this attitude—eat to live, not live to eat—we become selfless.

We don’t consume more than needed.

When this attitude becomes widespread, the environment, the planet—everything—takes care of itself.

If you take care of the minutes, the hours will take care of themselves.

If we develop this attitude—of being a part of the system and not above it, not something special—it will not only help our spiritual progress but also ensure the well-being of the physical system as well.

For such a person—who is always egoless, aware that everything is Brahman, and who performs niṣkāma karma (action without desire)—the state of Brahman is naturally attained.

The object, subject, verb, and adverb—all are Brahman!

Language Aspects of the Śloka

The key word here is Brahman. We should first be clear on the various similar words that have different meanings:
  • brahman (brahma) = ब्रह्मन् (ब्रह्म) = Supreme divinity, beyond classification, the source of all, the all!
  • brahmā = ब्रह्मा = The creator aspect of the divine.
  • brāhmaṇa = ब्राह्मण = One of the four varṇas (classes) of society, originally based on qualities and deeds, referring to scholars, philosophers, and thinkers.

Breakdown of the Verse
  • brahmārpaṇaṃ = brahma + arpaṇam
    • arpaṇam = The ladle, the instrument of offering.
    • brahmārpaṇaṃ = The instrument of offering is Brahman.
  • haviḥ = The offering itself.
    • (The sandhi would make it havirbrahmāgnau, but for simplicity, it is often broken apart.)
  • brahmāgnau = brahma + agnau
    • agni = Fire
    • agnau = In the fire
  • brahmaṇā = [The act is performed] by Brahman.
  • hutam = Offering.
    • (This means: The act of offering is by Brahman, and the offering itself is also Brahman.)
  • tena = By that.
  • brahmakarmasamādhinā = brahma + karma + samādhin + -ā
    • brahma-karma = Karma that is steadfast in Brahman, selfless deeds.
    • samādhin = One steadfast in samādhi.
    • samādhinā = By the samādhin.
    • (Thus: "By the one who is steadfast in brahma-karma.”)
  • brahmaiva = brahma + eva = Only Brahman.
  • gantavyaṃ = Destination.
    • gam = To go.
    • gantavyaṃ = Where one should go, the destination.



(c) Shashikant Joshi । शशिकांत जोशी । ॐ सर्वे भवन्तु सुखिनः ।

36 comments:

  1. Wonderfully expalained.

    ReplyDelete
  2. thank you, please do add your name and place in comments, gives it a personality :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Can you please explain the literal meaning of " brahmaiva tena gantavyaṃ"

    ReplyDelete
  4. brahma-karma-samAdhinA, tena gantavyam brahma eva (asti)

    those steadfast in 'karma as brahma' (selfless karma), destination (achieved by them ; -ena suffix) (is) brahma only.

    brahma only is the destination achieved by them (those in selfless karma)

    tena = (achieved, reached, etc) by them
    gantavyam = destination
    brahma = state of brahma
    eva = only

    hope this helps.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Kara gra vasta is a beautiful prayer now with Gauri a new perspective. In the article there is mention of another mantra for morning what is that manta and where can I read about that second manta you talk about.
    in gratitude for explaning it so clearly

    ReplyDelete
  6. very well explained - why do we eat and how should we eat. Keep up the good work

    ReplyDelete
  7. found this latin maxim by Quintilian - "Non ut edam vivo, sed vivam edo" which explicitly means 'i don't live to eat, but eat to live.' http://www.latin-dictionary.org/Non_ut_edam_vivo,_sed_vivam_edo

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am elated to discover this blog. I shall keep coming back.
    S K Sengupta, Kolkata

    ReplyDelete
  9. very clear explanation .Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks a lot........U did a great a thing....

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks a lot......U did a great thing

    ReplyDelete
  12. The way of explanation worth each words meaning is Simply superb...

    Santoshi
    Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hari OM Namaste
    Thanks for trying to educate us in Sanskrit.
    Stumbled upon your site while trying to learn Sanskrit. What is the gender of Brahma as used in this shloka? What is the derivation of the word "arpaNam"? How is "gantavyam" derived? Explain how "karma that is steadfast in Brahma" = "selfless karma". What does "selfless" really mean in this shloka? Is there any mention of selfless, or is that a "customary" interpretation of the phrase? I ask because I wonder if anything we do is really "selfless", even when we are trying to "reach" Brahma. By merely having the thought that "I" want to attain the state of Brahman, implies that "mind" is at work. It is the mind that drives the desire to get to Brahman. Atma cannot, since Atma is without properties of Prakrti. Infact, Atma, some may argue IS Brahman, viz Isha Upanishad. So if we engage in selfless actions, the implication is that we are doing for others, not ourselves. If we do that, how can the Atma of the individual attain Brahman? My understanding is that to attain Brahman, one has to go "inwardly", and to be engaged in selfless actions, implies we are doing actions for the "outter".
    Just some thoughts, and some queries. Your esteemed reply would be most graciously welcomed
    Hari OM
    Namaste
    Student of Sanskrit

    ReplyDelete
  14. नमस्ते Student of Sanskrit,
    > What is the gender of Brahma as used in this shloka?
    नपुंसकलिङ्गम्।


    ReplyDelete
  15. Very beautiful explained. Thank you very much.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Rays6302 question is very relevant we must discover the truth of Aham Brahmasmi
    Om Shanti Shanti Shanti
    Neil McDermott Ireland

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thank you for making it applied to daily life. I would like to learn similar vyakhyanam of a few other slokas. I am an atheist-scientist. I find that the great knowledge is often for people like me too! Making it for all human beings would be a great service!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hari ohm. You clearly explain so no question arises. Guru kriypa hi kebalam

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks Sashi for the beautiful explaination. Also Rays63302 has raised a pertinent question. What does the act of 'selfless' actually mean? To Answer this is bit difficult, but only till the time you understand. Realistically and ultimately both the selfish and selfless student try to perform to their potential in the examination hall so that they come first. By the way,Who wants to be missed out? The point to understand is you can come first only if you clear the paper in style; And, to clear the paper, you have to study well. Then what's the big deal about being a selfless student? Well he is the Yogi and part of the Brahmam. He is tireless in action, because he is not unduly perturbed about the results, although he is doing the best.He is not nervous and is bold in doing. Similarly after the results also he continues to work well whether he has come first rank or not. Also if he has achieved a good result, he gives/shares innediately the extra or the needless wealth to the poor and needy without any hesitation.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks Sashi for the beautiful explaination. Also Rays63302 has raised a pertinent question. What does the act of 'selfless' actually mean? To Answer this is bit difficult, but only till the time you understand. Realistically and ultimately both the selfish and selfless student try to perform to their potential in the examination hall so that they come first. By the way,Who wants to be missed out? The point to understand is you can come first only if you clear the paper in style; And, to clear the paper, you have to study well. Then what's the big deal about being a selfless student? Well he is the Yogi and part of the Brahmam. He is tireless in action, because he is not unduly perturbed about the results, although he is doing the best.He is not nervous and is bold in doing. Similarly after the results also he continues to work well whether he has come first rank or not. Also if he has achieved a good result, he gives/shares innediately the extra or the needless wealth to the poor and needy without any hesitation.
    Krishnan from Kukatpally Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks Sashi for the beautiful explaination. Also Rays63302 has raised a pertinent question. What does the act of 'selfless' actually mean? To Answer this is bit difficult, but only till the time you understand. Realistically and ultimately both the selfish and selfless student try to perform to their potential in the examination hall so that they come first. By the way,Who wants to be missed out? The point to understand is you can come first only if you clear the paper in style; And, to clear the paper, you have to study well. Then what's the big deal about being a selfless student? Well he is the Yogi and part of the Brahmam. He is tireless in action, because he is not unduly perturbed about the results, although he is doing the best.He is not nervous and is bold in doing. Similarly after the results also he continues to work well whether he has come first rank or not. Also if he has achieved a good result, he gives/shares innediately the extra or the needless wealth to the poor and needy without any hesitation.
    Krishnan from Kukatpally Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  22. Good endeavour to explain the shaloka meaning. Sanskrit is marvelous language to which we have deliberately deprived by our politicians so that we may remain illiterate culturally despite getting education degrees from the universities.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Very neat and descriptive explanation. Thanks a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  24. thanks for your efforts,it seriously gives a brief , effective and factual description

    ReplyDelete
  25. Literally beautifully explained but what I didn't understood is that reaching to the state of brahman, isn't a desire? How this shows we are selfless? Means actually if we have to acquire brahmaism we have to have a desire and if we desire of anything then we have to be a bit selfish so how come selfless.
    By the way, I do work on the fact
    "Eat to live not live to eat"
    If you can then please clear me of selflessness, I think I merely know of selflessness.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Pranams !! Very nicely explained with examples that is helping a very wide subject understand in a practical manner. It is also helping me in imbibing and memorizing this verse. Dhanyavad !!.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Hari Om,

    Wonderful explanation, very clear !!

    Thank you

    Raj
    United States

    ReplyDelete
  28. beautifully explained. I am delighted. can you suggest me a simple beginners book on sanskrit learning? Rajagopal K S

    ReplyDelete

Please do add your name and place, after the comment.